. Copyright 2003, george-orwell.org
. Privacy Policy .
|  Hektoen InternationalA Journal of Medical Humanities  “How the Poor Die” by George Orwell, 1946 The next moment . . . the doctor and the students came across to my bed, hoisted me upright and without a word began applying the same set of glasses, which had not been sterilized in any way. A few feeble protests that I uttered got no more response than if I had been an animal. . . . They only put on six glasses in my case, but after doing so they scarified the blisters and applied the glasses again. Each glass now drew about a dessert-spoonful of dark-coloured blood. As I lay down again, humiliated, disgusted and frightened . . . there was another treatment coming, the mustard poultice. . . . Two slatternly nurses had already got the poultice ready, and they lashed it round my chest as tight as a strait-jacket while some men who were wandering about the ward in shirt and trousers began to collect round my bed with half-sympathetic grins. I learned later that watching a patient have a mustard poultice was a favorite pastime in the ward. . . . For the first five minutes the pain is severe, but you believe you can bear it. During the second five minutes this belief evaporates, but the poultice is buckled at the back and you can’t get it off. This is the period the onlookers enjoy most. During the last five minutes, I noted, a sort of numbness supervenes. . . . There was a light in the ward, enough to see by. I could see old Numéro 57 lying crumpled up on his side, his face sticking out over the side of the bed, and towards me. He had died sometime during the night, nobody knew when. When the nurses came they received the news of his death indifferently and went about their work. After a long time, an hour or more, two other nurses marched in abreast like soldiers, with a great clumping of sabots, and knotted the corpse up in the sheets, but it was not removed till some time later. . . . This business of people just dying like animals, for instance, with nobody standing by, nobody interested, the death not even noticed till the morning—this happened more than once. In How the Poor Die, George Orwell describes being treated for pneumonia in Paris in a hospital for the poor in 1929. He is put through a third degree by being interrogated at length by clerk, then marched without slippers through the snow while shivering from a high fever. He enters a low ill-lit room full of murmuring voices, three rows of beds so close that patients can touch each other. A foul, sweetish, fecal smell pervades the area, scraps of food and dirty dressings are discarded in the ward in a huge packing case infested by crickets. The nurses wake the patients at 5 am, take their temperature but do not wash them. Breakfast consists of a thin vegetable soup with slimy hunks of bread floating about in it. Rounds are made by a tall, solemn, black-bearded doctor followed by a retinue of interns and students. Day after day they walk past some of the beds, ignoring the imploring cries for help. They only stop at interesting cases, where students excitedly line up to palpate, percuss, auscultate. The patients have no privacy. They lie exposed, they suffer, urinate, and defecate in public view. They are treated like animals. They die alone, their organs already marked for a bottle in the museum, their bodies designated for dissection. Fortunately, as Dr. Davies points out in his review, such horrible conditions had become a thing of the past, even at the time when George Orwell wrote his classical essay. - Davies, P. How the Poor Die. BMJ 2012; 345:32.
- Orwell, G. How the Poor Die , 1946.
Leave a Reply Cancel replyYour email address will not be published. Required fields are marked * This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed . Intended for healthcare professionals - My email alerts
- BMA member login
- Username * Password * Forgot your log in details? Need to activate BMA Member Log In Log in via OpenAthens Log in via your institution
 Search form- Advanced search
- Search responses
- Search blogs
- News & Views
How the Poor Die- Related content
- Peer review
- Peter Davies , freelance journalist, London
- petergdavies{at}ntlworld.com
In the year the NHS Act became law, George Orwell recalls in his essay “How the Poor Die” the squalor and primitive treatments he encountered during his first stay in the public ward of a hospital, in Paris in 1929. Described as “Hôpital X,” it was the Hôpital Cochin, which still exists, though with a much improved reputation. Orwell is admitted with pneumonia, and undergoes cupping and is given a mustard poultice—like every patient regardless of their condition: “You got very little treatment at all, either good or bad, unless you were ill in some interesting and instructive … Log in using your username and passwordBMA Member Log In If you have a subscription to The BMJ, log in: - Need to activate
- Log in via institution
- Log in via OpenAthens
Log in through your institutionSubscribe from £184 *. Subscribe and get access to all BMJ articles, and much more. * For online subscription Access this article for 1 day for: £50 / $60/ €56 ( excludes VAT ) You can download a PDF version for your personal record. Buy this article  - DOI: 10.1136/BMJ.E6699
- Corpus ID: 71167351
How the Poor Die- Published in British medical journal 4 October 2012
- Medicine, Sociology
12 CitationsThe way we die now: a personal reflection, revolutionary medicine: a response to corporatizing healthcare in india, from theft to donation: dissection, organ donation and collective memory, intelligent kindness, teaching bioethics through literature, the history of respiratory disease management, building resilient health systems: patient safety during covid-19 and lessons for the future, water insecurity and urban poverty in the global south: implications for health and human biology, wraak en goede zorg, related papers. Showing 1 through 3 of 0 Related Papers ../ggcms/src/templates/revoltsource/view/display_childof_writings.php Not Logged In: Login? Author : George OrwellEnglish Novelist, Essayist, Journalist, Critic, Supporter of Democratic Socialism, Opponent of Authoritarianism, and Proven Undercover Agent Reporting on the Left to the Police : An English novelist, essayist, journalist, and critic. His work is characterised by lucid prose, social criticism, opposition to totalitarianism, and support of democratic socialism. Orwell produced literary criticism, poetry, fiction and polemical journalism. He is known for the allegorical novella Animal Farm (1945) and the dystopian novel Nineteen Eighty-Four (1949). (From: Wikipedia.org.) "How the Poor Die," by George Orwell, 1946. Quotes from How the Poor Die, by George OrwellLogin to Comment No comments so far. You can be the first! | | | | | , by , by , by , by , by , by , by , by , by , by , by , by , by , by , by , by , by , by , by , by |
- Today's news
- Reviews and deals
- Climate change
- 2024 election
- Newsletters
- Fall allergies
- Health news
- Mental health
- Sexual health
- Family health
- So mini ways
- Unapologetically
- Buying guides
Entertainment- How to Watch
- My watchlist
- Stock market
- Biden economy
- Personal finance
- Stocks: most active
- Stocks: gainers
- Stocks: losers
- Trending tickers
- World indices
- US Treasury bonds
- Top mutual funds
- Highest open interest
- Highest implied volatility
- Currency converter
- Basic materials
- Communication services
- Consumer cyclical
- Consumer defensive
- Financial services
- Industrials
- Real estate
- Mutual funds
- Credit cards
- Balance transfer cards
- Cash back cards
- Rewards cards
- Travel cards
- Online checking
- High-yield savings
- Money market
- Home equity loan
- Personal loans
- Student loans
- Options pit
- Fantasy football
- Pro Pick 'Em
- College Pick 'Em
- Fantasy baseball
- Fantasy hockey
- Fantasy basketball
- Download the app
- Daily fantasy
- Scores and schedules
- GameChannel
- World Baseball Classic
- Premier League
- CONCACAF League
- Champions League
- Motorsports
- Horse racing
New on YahooFact Check: George Orwell Did Say, 'At 50, Everyone Has the Face He Deserves'British author George Orwell once said: "At 50, everyone has the face he deserves." For years, social media users on X , Facebook , Instagram , and other platforms have claimed George Orwell, the British author best known for his novels "1984" and "Animal Farm," once said: "At 50, everyone has the face he deserves." The alleged quote has also appeared on numerous quote-meme websites , as well as in multiple print anthologies of quotes . (X user @holdengraber) Like other historical figures, such as Abraham Lincoln and Winston Churchill, Orwell has been a magnet for falsely attributed quotes, some of which Snopes has debunked before. In this case, however, the quote was genuine and correctly attributed to the British author. Searching for the quotation using the Internet Archive's full-text search function produced nearly 300 results . One of these was "In Front of Your Nose: 1945–1950," the fourth volume of the "Collected Essays, Journalism and Letters of George Orwell," which first published in 1968 and was co-edited by Sonia Orwell — his wife — and Ian Angus. The quote in question appeared on page 515 of that book, in a section titled "Extracts from a Manuscript Note-book." It is surrounded by a red box in the image below. The entry containing the quote was dated April 17, 1949. (Internet Archive/"Collected Essays, Journalism and Letters of George Orwell") In an introductory note to that section, the editors of the volume wrote: During the last year of his life Orwell kept a manuscript note-book in which he made notes for a long short story, "A Smoking Room Story," and for essays on Joseph Conrad and Evelyn Waugh. He also used it for occasional jottings from which the following selection is taken. Snopes tracked down a digitized version of the aforementioned notebook that was hosted online as part of University College London's George Orwell Archive . The quotation in question appeared in Orwell's handwriting on page 30 of the digitized version, at the bottom of the left page (highlighted in the red box). (George Orwell, "Literary Notebook [1949]") Although the quote itself was genuine, one piece of misinformation sometimes circulates alongside it. Namely, some social media users incorrectly claim it represented Orwell's last written words . (Facebook account QI - Quite Interesting) The same claim has also appeared in traditional publications , including a 2010 anthology titled "Last Words of Notable People," which identified the quote as Orwell's "last words (written)." That anthology cited another book, Ralph Keyes' 2006 "The Quote Verifier," which described the quote as "the last words Orwell wrote in his notebook." However, by reading through the digitized version of Orwell's original notebook, which continued for several pages after the quote in question appeared, Snopes found this was not the last thing Orwell ever wrote. The latest specific date we found in that notebook was Dec. 16, 1949, around eight months after Orwell jotted down the quotation investigated here, and one month before he died on Jan. 21, 1950, at the age of 46. The Dec. 16, 1949, date appeared on the left side of page 31 of the digitized notebook, in the form "16-12-49" (in British English, the day is placed before the month). In other words, "At 50, everyone has the face he deserves" was not the final sentence Orwell wrote before his death, despite occasional claims that it was. Instead, it was simply the final excerpt from his notebooks to be included in the fourth volume of the "Collected Essays, Journalism and Letters of George Orwell." Regardless, the presence of the quote in Orwell's own handwriting within one of his notebooks was sufficient evidence to confirm the quote's attribution. Therefore, Snopes rated the claim that Orwell once said, "at 50, everyone has the face he deserves" as a "Correct Attribution." Belmonte, Adriana. "9 of the Most Chilling Last Words in History." Business Insider, https://www.businessinsider.com/chilling-last-words-history-2018-6 . Accessed 20 Aug. 2024. ---. "9 of the Most Chilling Last Words in History." Business Insider, https://www.businessinsider.com/chilling-last-words-history-2018-6 . Accessed 20 Aug. 2024. Ibrahim, Nur. "Did Orwell Really Write This About Corrupt Politicians and Voters?" Snopes, 30 Nov. 2020, https://www.snopes.com//fact-check/george-orwell-people-accomplices/ . Maguire, Jack. Everyday Quotations : Just the Right Words for Life's Memorable Occasions. Garden City, N.Y. : GuildAmerica Books, 1998. Internet Archive, http://archive.org/details/everydayquotatio00magu . Malone, Aubrey. Quotable Quotes for Quoters. Tadworth : Clarion, 2005. Internet Archive, http://archive.org/details/quotablequotesfo0000malo . Orwell, George. "Literary Notebook [1949]." UCL Library Services, https://ucl.primo.exlibrisgroup.com/discovery/delivery/44UCL_INST:UCL_VU2/12414871860004761#page=30&zoom=150,-4,563 . ---. The Collected Essays, Journalism, and Letters of George Orwell. New York : Harcourt, Brace & World, Inc., 1968. Internet Archive, http://archive.org/details/collectessayorwe00geor . PerryCook, Taija. "Orwell Talked of 'Destroying People' by 'Denying and Obliterating' Their History?" Snopes, 21 June 2024, https://www.snopes.com//fact-check/george-orwell-destroying-people/ . Quotations for Speeches. London : Paragon Books, 1994. Internet Archive, http://archive.org/details/quotationsforspe0000unse_e6p2 . Ralph Keyes. The Quote Verifier. St. Martin's Press, 2006. Internet Archive, http://archive.org/details/quoteverifierwho00keye . |
IMAGES
COMMENTS
How the Poor Die, the essay of George Orwell. First published: November 1946 by/in Now, GB, London ... George Orwell How the Poor Die. In the year 1929 I spent several weeks in the Hôpital X, in the fifteenth arrondissement of Paris. The clerks put me through the usual third-degree at the reception desk, and indeed I was kept answering ...
How the Poor Die. " How the Poor Die " is an essay first published in 1946 in Now by the English author George Orwell. Orwell gives an anecdotal account of his experiences in a French public hospital that triggers a contemplation of hospital literature in the context of 19th-century medicine.
Get an answer for 'Discuss the pathos in George Orwell's essay "How the Poor Die," describing a French hospital's public ward.' and find homework help for other George Orwell questions at eNotes.
The complete works of george orwell, searchable format. Also contains a biography and quotes by George Orwell. ... Click on any of the links on the right menubar to browse through How The Poor Die. Index Index. Essay. Other Authors: > Charles Darwin > Charles Dickens > Mark Twain > William Shakespeare.
George Orwell's essay 'How the Poor Die'. - First published in 1946. - 'At five in the morning the nurses came round, woke the patients and took their temperatures, but did not wash them. ... George Orwell How the Poor Die, 1946 [L.m./F.s.: 2019-12-29 / 0.15 KiB] 'At five in the morning the nurses came round, woke the patients and took their ...
His experiences there were the basis of his essay "How the Poor Die", published in 1946 (though he chose not to identify the hospital). Shortly afterwards, he had all his money stolen from his lodging house. ... Peter Davison's publication of the Complete Works of George Orwell, completed in 2000, [297] [298] made most of the Orwell Archive ...
In How the Poor Die, George Orwell describes being treated for pneumonia in Paris in a hospital for the poor in 1929. He is put through a third degree by being interrogated at length by clerk, then marched without slippers through the snow while shivering from a high fever. He enters a low ill-lit room full of murmuring voices, three rows of ...
👍 This video is part of the collection with articles published by George Orwell in the period between 1931 and 1949. ⏰ Save the Playlist Fifty Orwell Essays...
The page where you can choose your language - top page of George Orwell's essay 'How the Poor Die' - Dag's Orwell Project. How the Poor Die. George Orwell. Choose your language: English language [L. m.: 2019-12-29]
George Orwell. 3.73. 253 ratings45 reviews. "How the Poor Die" is an essay published in 1946 by George Orwell. Orwell gives an anecdotal account of his experiences in a French public hospital which triggers a contemplation of hospital literature in the context of 19th-century medicine. Genres Nonfiction Essays Classics Short Stories Death ...
Here's the essay: How the Poor Die, by George Orwell, 1946: In the year 1929 I spent several weeks in the Hôpital X, in the fifteenth arrondissement of Paris. The clerks put me through the usual third-degree at the reception desk, and indeed I was kept answering questions for some twenty minutes before they would let me in.
In the year the NHS Act became law, George Orwell recalls in his essay "How the Poor Die" the squalor and primitive treatments he encountered during his first stay in the public ward of a hospital, in Paris in 1929. Described as "Hôpital X," it was the Hôpital Cochin, which still exists, though with a much improved reputation. Orwell is admitted with pneumonia, and undergoes cupping ...
"How the Poor Die" is an essay first published in 1946 in Now by the English author George Orwell. Orwell gives an anecdotal account of his experiences in a ...
Written by: George OrwellNarrated by: Ryllan Dobbelsteyn@flamenportunalis
In the year the NHS Act became law, George Orwell recalls in his essay "How the Poor Die" the squalor and primitive treatments he encountered during his first stay in the public ward of a hospital, in Paris in 1929. Described as "Hopital X," it was the Hopital Cochin, which still exists, though with a much improved reputation.
How the Poor Die - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. George Orwell summarizes his experience as a patient at Hospital X in Paris. He describes the difficult admission process where he had to answer unnecessary questions while having a high fever. Once admitted, he was given a cold bath and thin clothes ...
Throughout his essay, Orwell reflects on the history of medicine, medicinal practices and the beliefs that surrounded hospitals. "How the Poor Die" was published in 1946, but is believed to have been written during sometime between 1931 and 1936, when Orwell was a freelance writer focusing on the plight of the lower classes1.
Orwell produced literary criticism, poetry, fiction and polemical journalism. He is known for the allegorical novella Animal Farm (1945) and the dystopian novel Nineteen Eighty-Four (1949). (From: Wikipedia.org.) "How the Poor Die," by George Orwell, 1946.
In Why I Write, Orwell insists that all of his works after 1936 were written either "directly or indirectly, against totalitarianism and for democratic socialism.". This is evident in How the Poor Die, because Orwell argues that all citizens need to be treated with equal care in hospitals, regardless of their wealth--the basic aspect of ...
The page where you can choose your language - top page of George Orwell's essay 'How the Poor Die' - Dag's Orwell Project. How the Poor Die. George Orwell. Choose your language: English language [L. m.: 2019-12-29]
Author: George OrwellWork: How the Poor DiePublication: Now, [n.s.] No. 6, [November 1946]Wordcount: 4587Hashtags: #Orwell
The author of "1984" and "Animal Farm" died in 1950 at the age of 46. ... Journalism and Letters of George Orwell," which first published in 1968 and was co-edited by Sonia Orwell — his wife ...